Physician Compensation Is Evolving. Are Your Compensation Models Keeping Up?

onpost_follow

By Wes Brown, CPA, CVA, ABV, Director, Healthcare Services

Physician compensation has always been one of healthcare’s most challenging balancing acts. Today, that challenge is becoming even more complex.
 
Across the country, physician groups, hospitals, and health systems are facing growing pressure to recruit providers, retain top talent, align incentives with organizational goals, and remain financially sustainable. At the same time, provider expectations continue to evolve. Compensation discussions that once centered primarily on salary now include productivity incentives, quality metrics, student loan repayment, signing bonuses, ownership opportunities, deferred compensation arrangements, and long-term retention strategies.
 
Recently, during an industry conversation on provider compensation, I was asked which areas are generating the most questions from healthcare leaders today. My answer was immediate: primary care compensation, advanced practice provider (APP) incentives, and physician retention strategies. These topics are shaping compensation conversations in nearly every market.

Primary Care Compensation Is Changing Rapidly

One of the biggest shifts we’re seeing involves primary care physicians and APPs.

Healthcare organizations are working to adapt compensation plans to increasing demand for care, ongoing workforce shortages, and expanding value-based reimbursement programs. Primary care providers are responsible for more patients than ever, while organizations continue searching for ways to reward quality outcomes, improve patient access, and maintain provider satisfaction.
 
The challenge isn’t simply determining how much to pay providers. It’s determining which incentives actually drive the behaviors and outcomes organizations are trying to achieve.
 
Too often, organizations focus exclusively on market compensation surveys. While benchmarks are important, they rarely tell the entire story. A successful compensation plan must reflect provider productivity, organizational strategy, patient populations, reimbursement dynamics, and local market realities.
 
As I often tell clients, we’re trying to determine “true value data versus just data.” Compensation decisions require context, not simply numbers on a spreadsheet.

Recruitment Incentives Have Become Part of the Compensation Conversation

Provider shortages continue to drive competition for talent, particularly in rural and underserved markets.

As a result, healthcare organizations are becoming more creative in their recruitment strategies. Signing bonuses, residency stipends, fellowship support, relocation packages, and student loan repayment programs are increasingly common components of physician recruitment packages. 
 
Many organizations are beginning conversations with future providers earlier in their careers, sometimes during residency training, to create a clear pathway into communities struggling to attract physicians.
 
These arrangements can be highly effective when designed appropriately. However, they also require careful planning to address financial commitments, performance expectations, and long-term retention goals. A recruitment package should not simply help bring a provider through the door. It should support a successful, lasting relationship between the provider and the organization.

Ownership Opportunities Are Becoming More Important

Compensation isn’t always cash compensation.

For many physician groups and health systems, ownership opportunities are becoming an increasingly important component of provider retention and alignment strategies.
 
We continue to see growth in physician participation in ambulatory surgery center (ASC) joint ventures and other ownership arrangements that create shared financial interests between providers and healthcare organizations. These structures can help align incentives while supporting long-term organizational goals.
 
In some cases, associated real estate investments create additional opportunities for providers to participate in the long-term success of a healthcare facility. These arrangements require careful planning and regulatory consideration, but they can be powerful tools for strengthening provider engagement and retention.

Compensation Surveys Are a Starting Point, Not a Strategy

One of the most common mistakes I see is treating compensation surveys as the final answer.

Resources such as MGMA and other industry benchmarks can provide valuable perspective, but every compensation survey has limitations. Data collection methodologies differ. Organizations report compensation differently. Unique responsibilities such as medical directorships, call coverage, and administrative duties can significantly impact results.
 
Compensation surveys should establish guardrails, not dictate decisions.
 
The most successful organizations use benchmark data as one input among many. They combine market data with financial modeling, organizational objectives, provider expectations, and operational realities to create compensation plans that are sustainable and defensible.

Compensation Models Must Support Long-Term Sustainability

The most effective physician compensation plans recognize a simple reality: providers and organizations must succeed together.

When compensation plans are aligned with organizational goals, providers understand expectations, and incentives support desired outcomes, everyone benefits. When one side wins and the other loses, the relationship often becomes difficult to sustain.
 
As healthcare continues to evolve, compensation planning will remain one of the most important strategic decisions facing physician groups, hospitals, and health systems. Organizations that approach these decisions thoughtfully will be better positioned to recruit talent, retain providers, and support long-term growth.
 
At Kassouf, we work with physician groups, hospitals, health systems, and healthcare organizations to evaluate provider compensation models, benchmark physician compensation, assess recruitment strategies, and design plans that support both organizational objectives and provider success. Our healthcare team serves physicians, medical groups, hospital systems, payer organizations, accountable care organizations, and healthcare affiliates across a wide range of advisory and consulting engagements.
 
Want to hear more? Watch my recent conversation on provider compensation trends and healthcare workforce challenges with Ludi’s “5 Minutes with Eric” series.